Like a ring in a bell
So far today, four people -- in order, Avi Rappoport, Colin Barrett,
Jason Wright, and Jon Peltier -- have written to point out an odd
expression, "like a ring in a bell", in the second panel of
an xkcd cartoon:
an eggcorn, or what? The first three (plus posters on the
xkcd forums)
identified its source as Chuck Berry's "
Johnny B. Goode"
(released in 1958), where what Berry actually
sings is "like
a-ringin'
a bell" (Johnny B. Goode can play the guitar just like ringing a bell);
the original has been re-worked. The cartoon:
![](http://web.mac.com/arnold_zwicky/XkcdMondegreen.png)
What happened here? It starts with a kind of mishearing, in this
case a misparsing of the original, with the participial prefix
a- interpreted as the indefinite
article
a and the participle
ringin' (a verb form) taken to be
the noun
ring plus the
preposition
in. This is
a classic mondegreen (indeed, a phonetically perfect one). In the
resulting interpretation, the expression looks like some puzzling sort
of idiom. But then idioms generally don't make perfect sense;
sometimes we just live with them, content to see meaningful parts in
them.
Who knows who was the first to mishear Berry's original, or how many
people independently came to this analysis, but there are a few webhits
for it, most of them quotations of the song lyrics, as in
Because despite his challenges, Eddie
has a gift for music and he can play his uncle's guitar "like a ring in
a bell." (
link)
In this quote, and in the cartoon, what seems to be conveyed is the
ease or naturalness of an activity (something pretty close to the
reading I get for Berry's original). But in others, as in this
guitar review, the reference is to beautiful bell-like tone:
Beautiful sound, like a ring in a bell
that would make Johnny B Goode swoon! Really- it has a VERY nice ring-
good harmonics without brittle, ... (
link)
This looks like the road to eggcornville, with an opaque expression
reinterpreted so as to make its parts contribute more to the meaning of
the whole. Mondegreen, then eggcorn: a
MONDEGGCORN,
to use a term Ben Zimmer suggested on ADS-L back in August. On
the 14th, there was this memorable exchange between Ben and Joel Berson:
Zimmer: To be fair, Mark Peters' Babble
article on eggcorns includes a mondegreen ("You're a grand old flag,
you're a high-fivin' flag"), so it would be easy for a non-initiate to
miss the distinction.
Berson: But high-fiving is a celebratory act, so might not someone
think it fits with "grand old"?
Zimmer: Sure. It could very well be a mondeggcorn.
The day before, Wilson Gray had considered a blend analysis of an
example from his past:
Back in the day, a friend of ours was
under the impression that the once well-known brand-name, "Richard
_Hud_nut" was "Richard _Hug_nut," interpretable as "Hug_testicle_." We
laughed with him, till we realized that he was serious, at which point
we laughed *at* him.
And once Ben had posted on "high-fivin' flag", I replied to Wilson:
This looks like a mis-hearing of the
non-word "hud" as the phonetically *very* similar actual word "hug",
followed by a
rationalization of this perception in an analysis of the result as
involving "nut" 'testicle'. a little mondeggcorn (tm B. Zimmer).
No doubt there are other potential mondeggcorns in the Eggcorn Database.
Back to "a ring in a bell": Several correspondents noted the marked
character of the form
a-ringin'
for them -- archaic or regional or something. Quite so. The
a-V
in' form has been much studied (in
recent decades, by Wolf Wolfram with various collaborators); in the
U.S. these days, it's pretty much limited to some relatively isolated
areas (the Appalachians, the Ozarks, the Sea Islands), and even there
its use is declining. (For a summary of its properties, see the
discussion in
this handout
of mine.) It was once much more widespread in the U.S. (and the
U.K.), even standard, but now it reminds most people of
Hee-Haw or
The Beverly Hillbilles.
Posted by Arnold Zwicky at November 13, 2007 06:12 PM